His face contorted as he sputtered and coughed, but then everything about Daedalus smoothed out. He began to drink, then to gulp the liquid down, slurping when he reached the bottom of the bottle.

  “What is that?” Luce asked.

  “There is a chemical compound in the drink,” Daniel explained, “a dull poison mortals call aspartame and believe that their scientists invented. But it is an old, Heavenly substance—a venom, which, when mixed with an antidote contained in the alloy of the starshot, reacts to produce a healing potion for angels. For light ailments such as these.”

  “He will need to rest now,” the blond girl said. “But he will wake refreshed.”

  “You will forgive us if we have to leave,” Daniel said, rising to his feet. His white wings dragged along the rocky surface until he straightened his shoulders and held them aloft. He reached for Luce’s hand.

  “Go to your friends,” Phil said. “Vincent, Olianna, Sanders, and Emmet will accompany you. I will join you with the others when Daedalus is back on his wings.”

  The four Outcasts stepped forward, bowing their heads before Luce and Daniel as if awaiting a command.

  “We will fly the eastern route,” Daniel instructed. “North over the Black Sea, then west when we pass Moldova. The wind stream is calmer there.”

  “What about Gabbe and Molly and Cam?” Luce asked.

  Daniel looked at Phil, who looked up from the sleeping Outcast boy. “One of us will stand watch here. If your friends arrive, the Outcasts will send word.”

  “You have the pennon?” Daniel asked.

  Phil pivoted to show the abundant white feather tucked into the buttonhole of his lapel. It glowed and pulsed in the wind, its radiance sharply contrasting with the Outcast’s deathly pale skin.

  “I hope you have cause to use it.” Daniel’s words frightened Luce, because they meant he thought the angels in Avalon were in as much danger as the ones in Vienna.

  “They need us, Daniel,” she said. “Let’s go.”

  Daniel gave her a warm, grateful look. Then, without hesitation, he swept her up into his arms. With the halo tucked under their interlaced fingers, Daniel bent his knees and sprang into the sky.

  SIX

  FOUND WANTING

  It was drizzling in Vienna.

  Curtains of mist cloaked the city, making it possible for Daniel and the Outcasts to alight unseen on the eaves of a vast building before night had completely fallen.

  Luce saw the splendid copper dome first, glowing sea green against the fog. Daniel set her down before it on a slanted section of the copper roof, which was puddled with rainwater and enclosed by a short marble balustrade.

  “Where are we?” she asked, eyeing the dome adorned with gold tassels, its oval window frames etched with floral designs too high for mortal eyes to see, unless they were in the arms of an angel.

  “Hofburg Palace.” Daniel stepped over a stone rain gutter and stood at the edge of the roof. His wings brushed the white marble railing, making it look drab. “Home of Viennese emperors, then kings, now presidents.”

  “Is this where Arriane and the others are?”

  “I doubt it,” Daniel said. “But it’s a pleasant place to get our bearings before we look for them.”

  A mazelike network of annexes extended beyond the dome to form the rest of the palace. Some of them squared off around shady courtyards ten stories below; others stretched long and formidably straight, farther than the fog would allow Luce’s eyes to see. Different portions of the copper roofs shone different shades of green—this one acid, that one almost teal—as if sections of the building had been added over a long period of time, as if they’d rusted during different eras’ rains.

  The Outcasts spread out around the dome, leaning up against the squat chimneys darkened with soot that punctuated the palace roof, standing before the flagpole that rose from the center bearing the red-and-white-banded Austrian flag. Luce stood at Daniel’s side, finding herself between him and a marble statue. It depicted a warrior wearing a knight’s helmet and gripping a tall golden spear. They followed the statue’s gaze out at the city. Everything smelled like wood smoke and rain.

  Beneath the mist and fog, Vienna glittered with the twinkle of a million Christmas lights. It teemed with strange cars and fast-walking pedestrians as accustomed to city life as Luce was not. Mountains stood in the distance and the Danube slung its strong arm around the outskirts of the town. Gazing down with Daniel, Luce felt as if she’d been here before. She couldn’t be sure when, but the ever-more-frequent sensation of déjà vu swelled inside her.

  She focused on the faint bustle coming from a tented row of Christmas stalls in the circle below the palace, the way the candles flickered in their red and green globed glass lanterns, the way the children chased one another, pulling wooden dogs on wheels. Then it happened: She remembered with a wave of satisfaction that Daniel had once bought her crimson velvet hair ribbons right down there. The memory was simple, joyful, and hers.

  Lucifer couldn’t have it. He could not take it—or any other memory—away. Not from Luce, not from the brilliant, surprising, imperfect world sprawling out below her.

  Her body bristled with determination to defeat him, and with the rage of knowing that because of what he was doing, because she had rejected his wishes, all this might disappear.

  “What is it?” Daniel laid a hand on her shoulder.

  Luce didn’t want to say. She didn’t want Daniel to know that every time she thought of Lucifer she felt disgusted with herself.

  The wind surged around them, parting the mist that lay over the city to reveal an ambling Ferris wheel on the other side of the river. People twirled in its circle as if the world would never end, as if the wheel would spin forever.

  “Are you cold?” Daniel draped his white wing around her. The supernatural weight of it felt somehow overbearing, reminding her that her shortcomings as a mortal—and Daniel’s concern about them—were slowing them down.

  The truth was Luce was freezing, and hungry, and tired, but she didn’t want Daniel to coddle her. They had important things to do.

  “I’m fine.”

  “Luce, if you’re tired or afraid—”

  “I said I’m fine, Daniel,” she snapped. She didn’t mean to and felt sorry immediately.

  Through the blurring fog, she could make out horse-drawn carriages carting tourists and the hazy outlines of people tracing out their lives. Just like Luce was struggling to do.

  “Have I complained too much since we left Sword & Cross?” she asked.

  “No, you’ve been amazing—”

  “I’m not going to die or faint just because it’s cold and rainy.”

  “I know that.” Daniel’s directness surprised her. “I should have known you knew it, too. Generally, mortals are limited by their bodily needs and functions—food, sleep, warmth, shelter, oxygen, nagging fear of mortality, and so on. Because of that, most people wouldn’t be prepared to make this journey.”

  “I’ve come a long way, Daniel. I want to be here. I wouldn’t have let you go without me. It was a mutual agreement.”

  “Good, then listen to me: It is within your power to release yourself from mortal bonds. To be free of them.”

  “What? I don’t need to worry about the cold?”

  “Nope.”

  “Right.” She stuffed icy hands into the pockets of her jeans. “And apple strudel?”

  “Mind over matter.”

  A reluctant smile found her face. “Well, we’ve already established that you can breathe for me.”

  “Don’t underestimate yourself.” Daniel smiled back briefly. “This has to do more with you than me. Try it: Tell yourself that you are not cold, not hungry, not tired.”

  “All right.” Luce sighed. “I am not …” She’d started to mumble, disbelieving, but then she caught Daniel’s eye. Daniel, who believed she could do things she never thought she was capable of, who believed that her will meant the difference between having the halo and letting it slip away. She was holding it in her hands. Proof.

  Now he was telling her she had mortal needs only because she thought she did. She decided to give this crazy idea a try. She straightened her shoulders. She projected the words into the misty dusk. “I, Lucinda Price, am not cold, not hungry, not tired.”

  The wind blew, and the clock tower in the distance struck five—and something lifted off her so that she didn’t feel depleted anymore. She felt rested, equipped for whatever the night called for, determined to succeed.

  “Nice touch, Lucinda Price,” Daniel said. “Five senses transcended at five o’clock.”

  She reached for his wing, wrapped herself in it, let its warmth spread through her. This time, the weight of his wing welcomed her into a powerful new dimension. “I can do this.”

  Daniel’s lips brushed the top of her head. “I know.”

  When Luce turned from Daniel, she was surprised to find the Outcasts were no longer hovering, no longer staring at her through dead eyes.

  They were gone.

  “They’ve left to seek the Scale,” Daniel explained. “Daedalus gave us clues to their whereabouts, but I’ll need a better idea of if or where the others are being held so I can distract the Scale long enough for the Outcasts to rescue them.” He sat down on the ledge, his legs straddling a gold-painted statue of an eagle overlooking the city. Luce sank to his side.

  “It shouldn’t take long, depending on how far away they are. Then maybe half an hour to go through the Scale protocol”—he tilted his head, calculating—“unless they decide to convene a tribunal, which happened the last time they harassed me. I’ll find a way to get out of it tonight, postpone it to some other date I won’t keep.” He took her hand, refocused. “I should be back here by seven at the latest. That’s two hours from now.”

  Luce’s hair was wet from the mist, but she followed Daniel’s advice and told herself it didn’t affect her, and just like that, she no longer noticed it. “Are you worried about the others?”

  “The Scale won’t hurt them.”

  “Then why did they hurt Daedalus?”

  She pictured Arriane with bloated purple eyes, Roland with broken, bloody teeth. She didn’t want to see them looking anything like Daedalus.

  “Oh,” Daniel said. “The Scale can be fearsome. They relish causing pain, and they may cause our friends some temporary discomfort. But they won’t hurt them in any permanent way. They don’t kill. That’s not their style.”

  “What is their style, then?” Luce crossed her legs under her on the hard, damp surface of the roof. “You still haven’t told me who they are or what we’re up against.”

  “The Scale came into being after the Fall. They’re a small group of … lesser angels. They were the first to be asked in the Roll Call which side they would stand by, and they chose the Throne.”

  “There was a roll call?” Luce asked, not sure she’d heard correctly. It sounded more like homeroom than Heaven.

  “After the schism in Heaven, all of us were made to choose sides. So, starting with the angels with the smallest dominions, each of us was to be called upon to make an oath of fealty to the Throne.” He stared at the mist, and it was as though he could see it all again. “It took ages to call out the angels’ names, starting at the lowest ranked and working up. It probably took as long to say our names as it did for Rome to rise and fall. But they didn’t make it all the way through the Roll Call before—” Daniel took a ragged breath.

  “Before what?”

  “Before something happened to make the Throne lose faith in its host of angels …”

  By now Luce realized that when Daniel’s voice trailed off like that, it wasn’t because he didn’t trust her or because she wouldn’t understand, but because despite all the things she’d seen and learned, it still might be too soon for her to know the truth. So she didn’t ask—though she was desperate to—what had made the Throne abandon the Roll Call when its highest angels had not yet chosen sides. She let Daniel speak again when he was ready.

  “Heaven cast out everyone who had not sided with it. Remember how I told you a few angels never got to choose? They were among the last in the Roll Call, the highest. After the Fall, Heaven was bereft of most of its Archangels.” He closed his eyes. “The Scale, who had lucked into seeming loyal, stepped into the breach.”

  “So because the Scale swore fealty to Heaven first—” Luce said.

  “They felt they had a superior amount of honor,” Daniel said, finishing her thought. “Since then, they have self-righteously claimed to serve Heaven by acting as celestial parole officers. But the position is self-invented, not ordained. With the Archangels gone after the Fall, the Scale took advantage of a vacuum of power. They carved out a role for themselves, and they convinced the Throne of their importance.”

  “They lobbied God?”

  “More or less. They pledged to restore the fallen to Heaven, to gather back those angels who had strayed, to return them to the fold. They spent a handful of millennia urging us to recommit ourselves to the ‘right’ side, but somewhere along the way, they gave up trying to change our points of view. Now they mostly just try to prevent us from accomplishing anything.”

  His steely gaze showed his rage and it made Luce wonder what could be so bad in Heaven that it kept Daniel in self-exile. Wasn’t the peace of Heaven preferable to where he was now, with everyone waiting for him to choose?

  Daniel laughed bitterly. “But the angels worth their wings who have returned to Heaven don’t need the Scale to get there. Ask Gabbe, ask Arriane. The Scale is a joke. Still, they’ve had one or two successes.”

  “But not you?” she asked. “You haven’t chosen one side or the other. And so they’re after you, aren’t they?”

  A crowded red tram wound around the paved circle below, then forked up a narrow street.

  “They’ve been after me for years,” Daniel said, “planting lies, manufacturing scandals.”

  “And yet you haven’t declared for the Throne. Why haven’t you?”

  “I’ve told you. It’s not as simple as that,” he said.

  “But you’re clearly not going to side with Lucifer.”

  “Right, but … I can’t explain thousands of years’ worth of argument in the space of a few minutes. It is complicated by factors beyond my control.” He looked away again, out over the city, then down at his hands. “And it’s an insult to be asked to choose, an insult for your creator to demand that you reduce the vastness of your love to the tiny, petty confines of a gesture during a Roll Call.” He sighed. “I don’t know. Maybe I’m too sincere.”

  “No—” Luce started.

  “Anyway, the Scale. They’re Heavenly bureaucrats. I think of them as high school principals. Pushing papers and punishing minor transgressions of rules no one cares about or believes in, all in the name of ‘morality.’ ”

  Again Luce stared out at the city, which was drawing a dark coat around its shoulders. She thought of the sour-breathed vice-principal at Dover, whose name she couldn’t remember, who never had any interest in her side of any story, who had signed her expulsion papers after the fire that killed Trevor. “I’ve been burned by people like that.”

  “We all have. They’re sticklers for frivolous rules of their own invention, which they deem righteous. None of us like them, but unfortunately the Throne has given them the power to monitor us, to detain us without cause, to convict us of crimes by a jury of their choosing.”

  Luce shuddered again, this time not because of the cold. “And you think they have Arriane and Roland and Annabelle? Why? Why hold them?”

  Daniel sighed. “I know they have Arriane and Roland and Annabelle. Their hatred blinds them to the fact that delaying us helps Lucifer.” He swallowed hard. “What I fear most is that they also have the relic.”

  In the distance, four pairs of tattered wings materialized in the fog. Outcasts. As they neared the palace roof, Luce and Daniel rose to greet them.

  The Outcasts landed next to Luce, their wings crackling like paper umbrellas as they drew them to their sides. Their faces betrayed no emotion; nothing in their demeanor suggested that their trip had been successful.

  “Well?” Daniel asked.

  “The Scale have taken control of a place down the river,” Vincent announced, pointing in the direction of the Ferris wheel. “The neglected wing of a museum. It is under renovation, covered in scaffolding, so they stake it out unnoticed. It is not equipped with alarms.”

  “You’re certain they’re Scale?” Daniel asked quickly.

  One of the Outcasts nodded. “We perceived their brands, their gold insignias—the star with seven points for the seven holy virtues painted on their necks.”

  “What about Roland and Arriane and Annabelle?” Luce asked.

  “They are with the Scale. Their wings are bound,” Vincent said.

  Luce turned away, biting down on her lower lip. How awful it must be for an angel to have her wings restrained. She couldn’t bear to think of Arriane without the freedom to flutter her iridescent wings. She couldn’t imagine any substance strong enough to contain the power of Roland’s marbled wings.

  “Well, if we know where they are, let’s go rescue them already,” she said.

  “And the relic?” Daniel said lowly to Vincent.

  Luce gaped at him. “Daniel, our friends are in danger.”

  “Do they have it?” Daniel pressed. He glanced at Luce, put his hand around her waist. “Everything is in danger. We will save Arriane and the others, but we have to find that relic, too.”

  “We do not know about the relic.” Vincent shook his head. “The warehouse is heavily guarded, Daniel Grigori. They await your arrival.”

  Daniel faced the city, his violet eyes casting along the river as if seeking out the warehouse. His wings pulsed. “They won’t be waiting long.”

  “No!” Luce pleaded. “You’ll be walking into a trap. What if they take you hostage, the way they’ve taken the others?”