‘This is a very confusing situation,’ he said.

  Reacher said nothing back. Just sat and waited.

  ‘Exactly what happened at the restaurant?’ Deerfield asked.

  ‘Nothing happened,’ Reacher said.

  Deerfield shook his head. ‘You were under surveillance. My people have been following you for a week. Special Agents Poulton and Lamarr joined them tonight. They saw the whole thing.’

  Reacher stared at him. ‘You’ve been following me for a week?’

  Deerfield nodded. ‘Eight days, actually.’

  ‘Why?’

  ‘We’ll get to that later.’

  Lamarr stirred and reached down again to her briefcase. She pulled out another file. Opened it and took out a sheaf of papers. There were four or five sheets clipped together. They were covered in dense type. She smiled icily at Reacher and reversed the sheets and slid them across the table to him. The air caught them and riffed them apart. The clip dragged on the wood and stopped them exactly in front of him. In them Reacher was referred to as the subject. They were a list of everything he had done and everywhere he had been in the previous eight days. They were complete to the last second. And they were accurate to the last detail. Reacher glanced from them to Lamarr’s smiling face and nodded.

  ‘Well, FBI tails are obviously pretty good,’ he said. ‘I never noticed.’

  There was silence.

  ‘So what happened in the restaurant?’ Deerfield asked again.

  Reacher paused. Honesty is the best policy, he thought. He scoped it out. Swallowed. Then he nodded toward Blake and Lamarr and Poulton. ‘These law-school buffs would call it imperfect necessity, I guess. I committed a small crime to stop a bigger one happening.’

  ‘You were acting alone?’ Cozo asked.

  Reacher nodded. ‘Yes, I was.’

  ‘So what was don’t start a turf war with us all about?’

  ‘I wanted it to look convincing. I wanted Petrosian to take it seriously, whoever the hell he is. Like he was dealing with another organization.’

  Deerfield leaned all the way over the table and retrieved Lamarr’s surveillance log. He reversed it and riffed through it.

  ‘This shows no contact with anybody at all except Ms Jodie Jacob. She’s not running protection rackets. What about the phone log?’

  ‘You’re tapping my phone?’ Reacher asked.

  Deerfield nodded. ‘We’ve been through your garbage, too.’

  ‘Phone log is clear,’ Poulton said. ‘He spoke to nobody except Ms Jacob. He lives a quiet life.’

  ‘That right, Reacher?’ Deerfield asked. ‘You live a quiet life?’

  ‘Usually,’ Reacher said.

  ‘So you were acting alone,’ Deerfield said. ‘Just a concerned citizen. No contact with gangsters, no instructions by phone.’

  He turned to Cozo, a question in his eyes. ‘You comfortable with that, James?’

  Cozo shrugged and nodded. ‘I’ll have to be, I guess.’

  ‘Concerned citizen, right, Reacher?’ Deerfield said.

  Reacher nodded. Said nothing.

  ‘Can you prove that to us?’ Deerfield asked.

  Reacher shrugged. ‘I could have taken their guns. If I was connected, I would have. But I didn’t.’

  ‘No, you left them in the dumpster.’

  ‘I disabled them first.’

  ‘With grit in the mechanisms. Why did you do that?’

  ‘So nobody could find them and use them.’

  Deerfield nodded. ‘A concerned citizen. You saw an injustice, you wanted to set it straight.’

  Reacher nodded back. ‘I guess.’

  ‘Somebody’s got to do it, right?’

  ‘I guess,’ Reacher said again.

  ‘You don’t like injustice, right?’

  ‘I guess not.’

  ‘And you can tell the difference between right and wrong.’

  ‘I hope so.’

  ‘You don’t need the intervention of the proper authorities, because you can make your own decisions.’

  ‘Usually.’

  ‘Confident with your own moral code.’

  ‘I guess.’

  There was silence. Deerfield looked through the glare.

  ‘So why did you steal their money?’ he asked.

  Reacher shrugged. ‘Spoils of battle, I guess. Like a trophy.’

  Deerfield nodded. ‘Part of the code, right?’

  ‘I guess.’

  ‘You play to your own rules, right?’

  ‘Usually.’

  ‘You wouldn’t mug an old lady, but it was OK to take money off of a couple of hard men.’

  ‘I guess.’

  ‘When they step outside what’s acceptable to you, they get what they get, right?’

  ‘Right.’

  ‘A personal code.’

  Reacher shrugged again. Said nothing. The silence built.

  ‘You know anything about criminal profiling?’ Deerfield asked suddenly.

  Reacher paused. ‘Only what I read in the newspaper.’

  ‘It’s a science,’ Blake said. ‘We developed it at Quantico, over many years. Special Agent Lamarr here is currently our leading exponent. Special Agent Poulton is her assistant.’

  ‘We look at crime scenes,’ Lamarr said. ‘We look at the underlying psychological indicators, and we work out the type of personality which could have committed the crime.’

  ‘We study the victims,’ Poulton said. ‘We figure out to whom they could have been especially vulnerable.’

  ‘What crimes?’ Reacher asked. ‘What scenes?’

  ‘You son of a bitch,’ Lamarr said.

  ‘Amy Callan and Caroline Cooke,’ Blake said. ‘Both homicide victims.’

  Reacher stared at him.

  ‘Callan was first,’ Blake said. ‘Very distinctive MO, but one homicide is just one homicide, right? Then Cooke was hit. With the exact same MO. That made it a serial situation.’

  ‘We looked for a link,’ Poulton said. ‘Between the victims. Not hard to find. Army harassment complainants who subsequently quit.’

  ‘Extreme organization at the crime scene,’ Lamarr said. ‘Indicative of military precision, maybe. A bizarre, coded MO. Nothing left behind. No clues of any kind. The perpetrator was clearly a precise person, and clearly a person familiar with investigative procedures. Possibly a good investigator himself.’

  ‘No forced entry at either abode,’ Poulton said. ‘The killer was admitted to the house in both cases, by the victims, no questions asked.’

  ‘So the killer was somebody they both knew,’ Blake said.

  ‘Somebody they both trusted,’ Poulton said.

  ‘Like a friendly visitor,’ Lamarr said.

  There was silence in the room.

  ‘That’s what he was,’ Blake said. ‘A visitor. Somebody they regarded as a friend. Somebody they felt a bond with.’

  ‘A friend, visiting,’ Poulton said. ‘He knocks on the door, they open it up, they say hi, so nice to see you again.’

  ‘He walks in,’ Lamarr said. ‘Just like that.’

  There was silence in the room.

  ‘We explored the crime, psychologically,’ Lamarr said. ‘Why were those women making somebody mad enough to kill them? So we looked for an Army guy with a score to settle. Maybe somebody outraged by the idea of pesky women ruining good soldiers’ careers, and then quitting anyway. Frivolous women, driving good men to suicide?’

  ‘Somebody with a clear sense of right and wrong,’ Poulton said. ‘Somebody confident enough in his own code to set these injustices right by his own hand. Somebody happy to act without the proper authorities getting in the way, you know?’

  ‘Somebody both women knew,’ Blake said. ‘Somebody they knew well enough to let right in the house, no questions asked, like an old friend or something.’

  ‘Somebody decisive,’ Lamarr said. ‘Maybe like somebody organized enough to think for a second and then go buy a label machine and a tube of glue, just to take care of a little ad-hoc problem.’

  More silence.

  ‘The Army ran them through their computers,’ Lamarr said. ‘You’re right, they never knew each other. They had very few mutual acquaintances. Very few. But you were one of them.’

  ‘You want to know an interesting fact?’ Blake said. ‘Perpetrators of serial homicide used to drive Volkswagen Bugs. Almost all of them. It was uncanny. Then they switched to minivans. Then they switched to sport-utilities. Big four-wheel drives, exactly like yours. It’s a hell of an indicator.’

  Lamarr leaned across and pulled the sheaf of papers back from Deerfield’s place at the table. She tapped them with a finger.

  ‘They live solitary lives,’ she said. ‘They interact with one other person at most. They live off of other people, often relatives or friends, often women. They don’t do much normal stuff. Don’t talk much on the phone, they’re quiet and furtive.’

  ‘They’re law enforcement buffs,’ Poulton said. ‘They know all kinds of stuff. Like all kinds of obscure legal cases defining their rights.’

  More silence.

  ‘Profiling,’ Blake said. ‘It’s an exact science. It’s regarded as good enough evidence to get an arrest warrant in most states of the Union.’

  ‘It never fails,’ Lamarr said. She stared at Reacher and then she sat back with her crooked teeth showing in a satisfied smile. Silence settled over the room.

  ‘So?’ Reacher said.

  ‘So somebody killed two women,’ Deerfield said.

  ‘And?’

  Deerfield nodded to his right, toward Blake and Lamarr and Poulton. ‘And these agents think it was somebody exactly like you.’

  ‘So?’

  ‘So we asked you all those questions.’

  ‘And?’

  ‘And I think they’re absolutely right. It was somebody exactly like you. Maybe it even was you.’

  FOUR

  ‘No, it wasn’t me,’ Reacher said.

  Blake smiled. ‘That’s what they all say.’ Reacher stared at him. ‘You’re full of shit, Blake. You’ve got two women, is all. The Army thing is probably a coincidence. There are hundreds of women out there, harassed out of the Army, maybe thousands. Why jump on that connection?’

  Blake said nothing.

  ‘And why a guy like me?’ Reacher asked. ‘That’s just a guess, too. And that’s what this profiling crap comes down to, right? You say a guy like me did it because you think a guy like me did it. No evidence or anything.’

  ‘There is no evidence,’ Blake said.

  ‘The guy didn’t leave any behind,’ Lamarr said. ‘And that’s how we work. The perpetrator was obviously a smart guy, so we looked for a smart guy. You saying you’re not a smart guy?’

  Reacher stared at her. ‘There are thousands of guys as smart as me.’

  ‘No, there are millions, you conceited son of a bitch,’ she said. ‘But then we started narrowing it down some. A smart guy, a loner, Army, knew both victims, movements unaccounted for, a brutal vigilante personality. That narrowed it down from millions to thousands to hundreds to tens, maybe all the way on down to you.’

  There was silence.

  ‘Me?’ Reacher said to her. ‘You’re crazy.’

  He turned to Deerfield, who was sitting silent and impassive.

  ‘You think I did it?’

  Deerfield shrugged. ‘Well, if you didn’t, it was somebody exactly like you. And I know you put two guys in the hospital. You’re already in big trouble for that. This other matter, I’m not familiar with the case. But the Bureau trusts its experts. That’s why we hire them, after all.’

  ‘They’re wrong,’ Reacher said.

  ‘But can you prove that?’

  Reacher stared at him. ‘Do I have to? What about innocent until proven guilty?’

  Deerfield just smiled. ‘Please, let’s stay in the real world, OK?’

  There was silence.

  ‘Dates,’ Reacher said. ‘Give me dates, and places.’

  More silence. Deerfield stared into space.

  ‘Callan was seven weeks ago,’ Blake said. ‘Cooke was four.’

  Reacher scanned back in time. Four weeks was the start of fall, seven took him into late summer. Late summer, he had done nothing at all. He had been battling the yard. Three months of unchecked growth had seen him outdoors every day with scythes and hoes and other unaccustomed tools in his hands. He had gone days at a time without even seeing Jodie. She had been tied up with legal cases. She had spent a week overseas, in London. He couldn’t recall for sure which week it had been. It was a lonely spell, his time absorbed with beating rampant nature backward, a foot at a time.

  The start of fall, he’d transferred his energies inside the house. There were things to be done. But he’d done them all alone. Jodie had stayed in the city, working her way up the greasy pole. There were random nights together. But that was all. No trips anywhere, no ticket stubs, no hotel registers, no stamps in his passport. No alibis. He looked at the seven agents ranged against him.

  ‘I want my lawyer now,’ he said.

  The two local sentries took him back to the first room. His status had changed. This time they stayed inside with him, one standing on each side of the closed door. Reacher sat in the plastic garden chair and ignored them. He listened to the tireless fluttering of the ventilation inside the exposed trunking in the ceiling, and waited, thinking about nothing.

  He waited almost two hours. The two sentries stood patiently by the door, not looking at him, not speaking, never moving. He stayed in his chair, leaning back, staring at the ducts above his head. There were twin systems up there. One blew fresh air into the room and the other sucked stale air out. The layout was clear. He traced the flow lines with his eyes and imagined big lazy fans outside on the roof, turning slowly in opposite directions, making the building breathe like a lung. He imagined the spent breath from his body floating away into the Manhattan night sky and out toward the Atlantic. He imagined the damp molecules drifting and diffusing in the atmosphere, catching in the breeze and eddying away. Two hours, they could be twenty miles offshore. Or thirty. Or forty. It would depend on the conditions. He couldn’t remember if it had been a windy night. He guessed not. He recalled the fog. Fog would blow away if there was a decent wind. So it was a still night, and therefore his spent breath was probably hanging sullenly in the air right above the lazy fans.

  Then there were people in the corridor outside and the door opened and the sentries stepped out and Jodie walked in. She blazed against the grey walls. She was wearing a pastel peach dress with a wool coat over it, a couple of shades darker. Her hair was still lightened from the summer sun. Her eyes were bright blue, and her skin was the colour of honey. It was the middle of the night, and she looked as fresh as morning.

  ‘Hey, Reacher,’ she said.

  He nodded and said nothing. He could see worry in her face. She stepped close and bent down and kissed him on the lips. She smelled like a flower.

  ‘You talk to them?’ he asked her.

  ‘I’m not the right person to deal with this,’ she said. ‘Financial law, yes, but criminal law, I’ve got no idea.’

  She waited in front of his chair, tall and slim, head cocked to one side, all her weight on one foot. Every new time he saw her, she looked more beautiful. He stood up and stretched, wearily.

  ‘There’s nothing to deal with,’ he said.

  She shook her head. ‘Yes, there damn well is.’

  ‘I didn’t kill any women.’

  She stared at him. ‘Of course you didn’t. I know that. And they know that, or they’d have put you in handcuffs and leg-irons and taken you straight down to Quantico, not dumped you in here. This must be about the other thing. They saw you do that. You put two guys in the hospital, with them watching.’

  ‘It’s not about that. They reacted too fast. This was set up before I even did the other thing. And they don’t care about the other thing. I’m not working the rackets. That’s all Cozo’s interested in, organized crime.’

  She nodded. ‘Cozo’s happy. Maybe more than happy. He’s got two punks off the street, no cost to himself. But it’s turned into a Catch-22, don’t you see that? To convince Cozo, you had to make yourself out as a vigilante loner, and the more you made yourself out as a vigilante loner, the more you pushed yourself into this profile from Quantico. So whatever reason they brought you in for, you’re starting to confuse them.’

  ‘The profile is bullshit.’

  ‘They don’t think so.’

  ‘It has to be bullshit. It came up with me.’

  She shook her head. ‘No, it came up with somebody like you.’

  ‘Whatever, I should just walk out of here.’

  ‘You can’t do that. You’re in big trouble. Whatever else, they saw you beat on those guys, Reacher. FBI agents, on duty, for Christ’s sake.’

  ‘Those guys deserved it.’

  ‘Why?’

  ‘Because they were picking on somebody who didn’t need picking on.’

  ‘See? Now you’re making their case for them. A vigilante, with his own code.’

  He shrugged and looked away.

  ‘I’m not the right person for this,’ she said again. ‘I don’t do criminal law. You need a better lawyer.’

  ‘I don’t need any lawyer,’ he said.

  ‘Yes, Reacher, you need a lawyer. That’s for damn sure. This is for real. This is the FBI, for God’s sake.’

  He was silent for a long moment.

  ‘You have to take this seriously,’ she said.

  ‘I can’t,’ he said. ‘It’s bullshit. I didn’t kill any women.’

  ‘But you made yourself fit the profile. And now proving them wrong is going to be tough. Proving a negative always is. So you need a proper lawyer.’

  ‘They said I’m damaging your career. They said I’m not an ideal corporate husband.’

  ‘Well, that’s bullshit, too. And even if it was true, I wouldn’t care. I’m not saying get a different lawyer for my sake. I’m saying it for yours.’