She nodded.

  “And the party?”

  “You know, I was fearful at first about the beanstalk. I thought of the harm it could do to the foundations, the value it might take off the house, that kind of thing. But then all of a sudden I thought, What the hell! and woke up to how extraordinary it was. And do you know, I’m really quite fond of it. I’m having a botanist here tomorrow to have a look.” She glanced around at her friends. “Someone brought over some hooch. I’m afraid to say we’re all a little tipsy.”

  Jack sighed. “Does this mean you want to keep it?”

  “Why not? Is it doing any harm?”

  Jack had to admit that it wasn’t — yet. They both gazed at it for a moment. It quivered every now and then as growing stresses were released; they could almost see it grow larger in front of their eyes. His mother shivered in the cold air, and Jack draped his jacket over her shoulders.

  “Do you think it’s self-pollinating?” she asked.

  “I haven’t the slightest idea. Are you sure you want to keep it?”

  Mrs. Spratt patted her son’s hand reassuringly “Let’s leave it a couple of days. We can make a decision then.”

  They went indoors, where his mum’s friends harangued him about the positioning of speed cameras until he was finally able to tear himself away.

  When he got home, everything was peaceful. The young children were all asleep, Madeleine was in her darkroom, and Pandora was reading in the living room. Apart from the quiet sound of Prometheus playing a sad lament on his lute in the spare room, all was calm in the Spratt household. Jack went into his study, switched on his desk lamp and stared at his iQuang computer. It took him another hour to finish his report. The next morning at ten, he would present it to Briggs and officially close the case.

  Or so he thought.

  23. Mary’s Doubts

  DOG WALKERS FACE BODY-FINDING BAN

  Citizens who find a corpse while walking their dog may be fined if proposed legislation is made law, it was disclosed yesterday. The new measures, part of the Criminal Narrative Improvement Bill, have been drafted to avoid investigations looking clichéd once they reach the docudrama stage. Other offenses covered by the act will be motorists declaiming in a huffy tone, “Why don’t you catch burglars/real criminals for a change?” when caught speeding, if there is a documentary crew in attendance. Civil libertarians, motorist groups and dog walkers are said to be “outraged.”

  From Amazing Crime Stories editorial, December 9, 1997

  Mary couldn’t sleep. She sat in the bedroom of her dilapidated flying boathouse and watched the rippled patterns the light made on the ceiling. Chymes seemed confident that the Humpty case hadn’t ended, and that bothered her. It shouldn’t have been any of her business, and that bothered her, too. At six-thirty she got up, showered and drove into Reading while it was still dark, the languid movements of late revelers and the bustle of early tradesmen the only activity in the sleeping town.

  She had a coffee with the end of the night shift and at 8:00 A.M. went over to the Forensic Department to see if Skinner was by chance an early riser. He wasn’t, but she wanted to speak to him, so she sat outside his office until he arrived, coffee and papers in hand. He still had his bicycle clips on.

  “I’m DS Mary,” she said. “I’m working with DI Spratt.”

  She had expected a smirk when she said it but didn’t get one. Skinner was one of the friendlies.

  “A fine man is Jack. Come on inside.”

  He unlocked the door and let them both in. The strip lights flickered on, making Mary blink after the dinginess of the corridor.

  “So,” said Skinner, guessing her intention almost immediately, “more questions over the Humpty murder? Or is it about Mrs. Dumpty?”

  “Both.”

  He pulled off his bicycle clips. “Shoot.”

  “Five shots had been fired from Mrs. Dumpty’s.32,” she began,

  “yet we can only account for one. What happened to the other four?”

  But Skinner didn’t seem particularly puzzled.

  “The fact they were missing from the clip means nothing, Mary. She might never even had loaded them.”

  “So it’s not suspicious?”

  “I’m afraid not.”

  “What about not finding the spent cartridge in Winkie’s garden?”

  “Shells are often picked up by astute criminals, Mary. It’s fairly common knowledge that we can match a cartridge to a gun as easily as we can match a slug — often easier. Perps often use revolvers for just that reason.”

  “What about a.32 caliber being able to destroy Humpty?”

  He scratched his head. “I tend to agree with Mrs. Singh — I would have thought a larger caliber. He was very badly damaged. But we’re both guessing. Data on bullets going through large eggs is a little bit in short supply, as you might imagine.”

  “But if we had the spent slug?”

  “Oh, yes.” Skinner smiled. “If we had that, we could know for sure.”

  Mary thanked him and moved to go, but Skinner laid a hand on her wrist.

  “Be careful, Mary.”

  “How do you mean?”

  “Just that things are sometimes not always what they seem.”

  “I’m sorry?”

  “You’re new to Reading and new to Jack. Don’t underestimate him. He’s a better man than most people give him credit for.”

  “I still don’t understand.”

  Skinner stared at her through his thick pebble spectacles.

  “Some people at Reading are too powerful for the good of the service,” he said slowly, pointing at a buff envelope on his desk, right next to the evidence bag with the two weathered shotgun cartridges that needed to be returned, “and people talk out of turn at their peril. You can take the cartridges with you, but I wouldn’t want you to make a mistake and take that buff envelope as well. Do you understand?”

  She frowned but nodded her agreement, wished him good day and dutifully took both the evidence bag and the envelope.

  She had a look when she was in her car. The envelope contained crime-scene photographs of the Andersen’s Wood murder, and pretty gruesome they were, too. She went through them once, then again. If there was something going on, she was definitely missing it. She replaced the pictures inside the envelope, stuffed it under the seat of her car and headed off towards Spatchcock’s Gymnasium.

  Mr. Spatchcock was giving a morning keep-fit lesson to a group of women who were all a bit puffed and had begun to go red. She could almost hear the silent pleas for him to stop or at least slow down. She was glad to be able to help. She tapped on the glass and hoped Spatchcock recognized her. It didn’t do to start flashing police badges around people’s place of work — unless you needed to make a point, of course.

  But he did recognize her. He told his class to take a much-welcome break and trotted up to where Mary was waiting for him.

  “It’s DS Mary, isn’t it?”

  “It is, Mr. Spatchcock. I’d just like to ask you a few more questions.”

  “Of course. I was very sorry to hear about Mrs. Dumpty. She had been a client for about two years and, like many of my personal charges, a driven woman with appetites the same as anyone else.”

  “You were intimate?”

  “If that is how you like to phrase it, yes. You may not approve of what I do, but no one is hurt by it, and I fulfill an important role. Laura was a lot better than most; I think we even had an affection of sorts for each other. Anyway, I have a friend in the pathology lab who told me they thought Humpty had been murdered, so naturally I thought Laura would be in the frame. Of course, I knew she hadn’t killed him — and that’s why I called you straightaway.”

  “I’m sorry?”

  “Which part?”

  “The ‘hadn’t killed him’ part.”

  “Well, Sergeant,” he said in a quieter voice, “I was with her the night of the Spongg Charity Benefit. I have no proof, of course, but that’s why I contacted you.”

  “Wait,” said Mary, “I haven’t spoken to you at all since we met at the Cheery Egg on Tuesday morning.”

  “I know that. You weren’t there, so I spoke to the other officer.”

  “DI Spratt?”

  “No, the one who is always on TV with that annoying chirpy cockney sidekick.”

  “Friedland Chymes?”

  “That’s the one. I told him all about it. Did he not tell you?”

  “No,” replied Mary, suddenly feeling confused. She thanked him and walked outside to her car. If Flotsam had known about Spatchcock when she spoke to him at the coffeehouse the previous evening, why didn’t he tell her? Wasn’t she part of their team? Chymes, she knew, conducted his investigations in a strange way — perhaps this was part of some bigger plan — and Flotsam followed orders, just like her. But what if there was another reason for it? What if Chymes was waiting until Jack had closed the investigation before he reopened it? That would fit into his dramatic way of doing things. She pulled out her mobile and started to dial Jack, then snapped it shut again. She needed more information. She started the car and drove rapidly across to Grimm’s Road.

  She parked in the alleyway and, after consulting the diagram Skinner had sketched for her, attempted to find out where the spent slug had returned to earth. It seemed simple enough. Lining up Humpty’s entrance and exit wounds gave Mary a zone of probability the shape of a wedge with a twenty-degree spread up to a hundred feet from where Humpty was sitting when he was killed. She worked from the sharp edge of the wedge back, scouring the earth, rubbish and junk in the back alleyway that the simple plan had indicated. She searched for forty minutes in an increasing state of agitation until a sudden thought had her standing on an upturned dustbin to check in the guttering — and there it was, looking small, gray and innocuous. It had been only slightly deformed — an almost perfect specimen for Skinner to work with. Better than that, it was a.44 caliber. Even if Spatchcock had lied — and there didn’t seem any reason for him to do so — then Mrs. Dumpty had killed her ex-husband with another gun. Not out of the question, but out of the ordinary. The two facts together would be enough to keep the investigation open.

  “Well, well. DS Mary.”

  She turned around quickly. Standing in the alleyway was Friedland Chymes.

  “Sir,” she said, trying to hide her feelings of nervousness, and jumping down, “what are you doing here?”

  “The same thing as you, I suspect,” he replied. “Trying to get to the bottom of Humpty’s death. What have you discovered?”

  She stared at him, and he stared back. She had stumbled, but she had not yet fallen. She prayed she wouldn’t blow it.

  “I spoke to Mr. Spatchcock this morning.”

  Chymes wasn’t fazed for even a second. He smiled again.

  “You figured there was something hokey about the whole thing on your own, Mary? I’m very impressed. Jack’s about to roll over and wee on himself in Briggs’s office, but you’re out here hunting down the truth. I can’t begin to tell you how valuable I think you would be to my team.”

  Two hours earlier it would have been the single greatest compliment she’d ever received from anyone who wasn’t her mother. But he hadn’t answered her question. And Mary always liked to have an answer.

  “When did you know that Humpty had been shot, sir?”

  “Long before you,” he said. “Mrs. Singh is highly diligent — too much so, to my taste. She wanted to be a hundred percent sure of what she had before she called you. Myself, I’ll go with a seventy percent probability any day.”

  “You knew,” said Mary softly. “You knew the evening before about the shooting and about Spatchcock. You withheld crucial evidence from our investigation.”

  “No I didn’t. And it would be very wrong and detrimental to your career if you were to mention it again. Tell me what you know, Mary.”

  She paused for a moment, bit her lip and looked down — the full gamut of someone unable to come to a decision, and Friedland pounced.

  “I think you should tell me,” he said a little more forcefully.

  “You should know that I generally get what I want and that people who help me are rewarded. Conversely and contrariwise, people who withhold information from me rarely last the course. I’ll ask you once more, and I expect an answer: What have you found?”

  She felt herself grow hot as he stared her down.

  “Do you really have space for me on the team?”

  “We always need new blood,” came Flotsam’s voice from behind her. “I think it’s in your best interest to tell the Guv’nor what he needs to know. He’ll find out anyway, and then you will have thrown away the last chance of what might have been a very worthwhile friendship.”

  “I found the slug,” she stammered at last. “It’s a.44. With Spatchcock’s evidence it’s enough to keep the case open.”

  Chymes and Flotsam exchanged looks.

  “We concur. Bravo, Mary. We have underestimated you. A good DS is worth her weight in gold, whoever she works for. Now, the question you have to ask yourself is what exactly are you going to do next? Think carefully. Your career depends upon it.”

  She swallowed hard and held up her head. “Well, I kind of thought I’d call… um, SOCO and… I don’t know — DI Spratt?”

  There was silence for a moment.

  “That’s a very disappointing choice, Mary. You’re new to all this, so I’m going to cut you some slack. These sorts of potentially high-profile crimes are good for the justice system. For the most part, the public can’t be bothered to understand what we do, so there is nothing like a couple of easy-to-understand, solved celebrity murders to keep them in the picture and supportive of our efforts — especially during the summer season. Police approval always leaps up after the successful conclusion of one of my cases.”

  “Are you saying I shouldn’t call my DI?”

  “Look at it this way,” said Chymes as he glanced at his watch. “It’s ten to ten. Jack will be speaking to Briggs on the hour. If you had found that slug a half hour later, we wouldn’t even need to have this conversation. I think it would be better for all concerned that Jack doesn’t hear about the slug or Spatchcock’s statement until he has officially closed the case. There is nothing quite like one detective closing a case only for another to awaken it with a dramatic flourish, don’t you agree?”

  “Is it really necessary to make Spratt look such an idiot?”

  “Spratt is an idiot, Mary — haven’t you figured that out yet? Listen, the public needs its heroes. And I want you on my team. We’ve got the best facilities and the best cases — the cream of not just the Oxford & Berkshire force but most of the others, too. We often do international consultancies, and His Eminence the Jellyman frequently asks for advice. Do you to want to meet the Jellyman, Mary?”

  He put out his hand.

  “Here is my hand. Shake it and stand by my side. I won’t offer it again.”

  Mary Mary working for Friedland Chymes. She had dreamed of this since she was nine. She stared at Chymes with his winning smile and perfect teeth. It was the easiest decision she ever made.

  24. Briggs v. Spratt

  MAN RECOGNIZES SUSPECT IN RECONSTRUCTION

  Mr. James Tuffnel was in custody yesterday, having been recognized when he appeared in a reconstruction during Network Toad’s popular PerpCatch UK program. He was spotted by eagle-eyed, public-spirited father of three Desmond Miller. “There was no doubt in my mind,” said Mr. Miller at his home in Morecambe Bay today, “but the man in the armed-robbery reconstruction was definitely an actor that I had seen once before in a custard commercial.” Out-of-work actor Mr. Tuffnel remained unrepentant and told us, “Okay, I admit that I did it. I’m not proud of myself, but I need the money. I haven’t worked for eight weeks. Do you want to hear me do the ‘What is a man?’ speech?”

  From the Morecambe Trumpet, July 2, 2003

  Briggs beckoned Jack into his office and had him wait while he spoke on the phone to the workman redecorating his house. After an inordinately long ten minutes discussing the choice of wallpaper for the front room, he hung up and stared at Jack.

  “You’ve got a confession note?” he asked.

  Jack slid it across the table. It was in a clear plastic cover, and Briggs put on his glasses.

  “Verified by the handwriting people?”

  “Yes, sir. It’s definitely Mrs. Dumpty’s.”

  “Well,” said Briggs removing his spectacles, “I think that’s fairly straightforward, don’t you?”

  “But for the smaller-than-expected caliber pistol and the four missing cartridges, and — ”

  “And what?”

  “I just don’t think she killed him. We interviewed her at ten-thirty the morning of her ex-husband’s death. Less than ten hours. She loved him, sir, even after the split — most people dump their ex’s stuff as soon as the papers come through, but everything that was his was still in her house. I’m not convinced that a crime of passion would leave her so calm.”

  Briggs held up the suicide note. “And this? What do you make of this? I quote: ‘…I prayed for God to forgive me as I pulled the trigger.’ She had the motive, opportunity — but, best of all, she wrote a confession. This one’s over, Jack.”

  “She didn’t kill him, sir.”

  “Listen,” said Briggs, “I know the NCD means a lot to you, but we can’t justify the expense. We’ve got to make some hard choices, and I’m sure the budgetary meeting can make a generous settlement for early retirement. You’ve done good work, Jack, but it’s a question of priorities.”

  “I thought it was just the department getting canned?” said Jack, rising to his feet.

  “You are the department,” replied Briggs, also rising. “Where else were you going to work? CID? Don’t make me insult you by offering you traffic or something. The Humpty case is closed.”